The Black is not dice: developer statements, evidence report, and a plan that looks for the rule

- planner/knowledge.yaml: what the game's developer has said (paraphrased, dated, graded), what the Atlas does
  with each statement, and the open questions with the experiment that tests each.
- analysis/black/evidence.py -> analysis/reports/BLACK.md: counts from the runs. On the same recorded route the
  shadow shows on 21 of 79 first attempts and 1 of 80 later ones; no single route; Blue then Black after the shadow.
- game.yaml: the shadow is a guard (not a roll); what follows it is the Blue, then the Black; on-screen text for
  the squad's direction screen.
- planner/experiments.yaml v2: one exact path on every fresh account (fresh-replicate), then one choice changed
  at a time (fresh-ablate); shadow-again, second-attempt-same-path, veteran-repeat, veteran-variety; what the bot
  records about the account; the sequence to follow once the shadow shows.
- solver.js: assign() takes account facts, account offsets and cycled arms; recommendOption() answers the
  squad screen (stay + direction) in one pick.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014jqCC2LZ4x1WHQ1V57nTsv
This commit is contained in:
ekcSchiano
2026-11-16 15:24:03 +00:00
co-authored by Claude Fable 5.2
parent 51842e1aa9
commit d01ec46fcc
19 changed files with 1588 additions and 231 deletions
+641 -87
View File
@@ -1,19 +1,92 @@
{
"schema": 1,
"seed": 20261112,
"schema": 2,
"seed": 20261116,
"lifecycle": {
"research_days": 3,
"retire": true,
"long_lived": {
"every": 10,
"take": 1
"take": 2
}
},
"record": [
"accountSeq",
"accountAttempt",
"accountCreatedAt",
"wing",
"section",
"squad",
"sawShadowBefore"
],
"scripts": {
"shadow": [
{
"step": "the tree top",
"take": "shadow",
"never": "green|descend"
},
{
"step": "asked to turn back",
"take": "stay the course|certain you saw",
"never": "second thought|green"
},
{
"step": "asked again",
"take": "intriguing|even if this kills",
"never": "second thought|green"
},
{
"step": "the Blue lands",
"take": "freeze and lower",
"never": "approach|run"
},
{
"step": "another cadet arrives",
"take": "hold (completely )?still",
"never": "warn|turn while|approach"
},
{
"step": "the Blue burns the cadet",
"take": "hold (your )?position",
"never": "interven|approach|warn"
},
{
"step": "the Blue judges",
"take": "head lowered|await.*judg",
"never": "approach|sure"
},
{
"step": "the Blue has left",
"take": "help the .*cadet",
"never": ""
},
{
"step": "the cadet's burns",
"take": "wrap|cut .*sleeve|dagger to cut",
"never": ""
},
{
"step": "moving on",
"take": "head south",
"never": ""
},
{
"step": "a branch snaps",
"take": "turn to face",
"never": "ignore"
},
{
"step": "the Black",
"take": "hold (its|it's|the) gaze|lift your chin",
"never": "lower your eyes"
}
]
},
"experiments": [
{
"id": "first-attempt-shadow",
"id": "fresh-replicate",
"status": "running",
"question": "How often does the shadow appear on an account's first attempt, and does heading West (at the start, at the fork) raise it?",
"question": "On a fresh account, does one exact path always show the shadow, sometimes, or never?",
"attempts": {
"from": 1,
"to": 1
@@ -24,7 +97,7 @@
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261112,
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
@@ -35,77 +108,18 @@
},
"arms": [
{
"id": "direction=West / post=West",
"levels": {
"direction": "West",
"post": "West"
},
"id": "all",
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"hour": "Tree",
"direction": "West",
"post": "West"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 60
}
},
{
"id": "direction=West / post=East",
"levels": {
"direction": "West",
"post": "East"
},
"fix": {
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"hour": "Tree",
"direction": "West",
"post": "East"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 60
}
},
{
"id": "direction=East / post=West",
"levels": {
"direction": "East",
"post": "West"
},
"fix": {
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"hour": "Tree",
"direction": "East",
"post": "West"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 60
}
},
{
"id": "direction=East / post=East",
"levels": {
"direction": "East",
"post": "East"
},
"fix": {
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"hour": "Tree",
"direction": "East",
"post": "East"
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
@@ -123,9 +137,392 @@
}
},
{
"id": "attempt-2-shadow",
"id": "fresh-ablate",
"status": "waiting",
"note": "starts when fresh-replicate is complete",
"question": "Which choices on that path does the shadow need?",
"attempts": {
"from": 1,
"to": 1
},
"unit": "account",
"share": 1,
"exclusive": true,
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
},
"burn": {
"reason": "TREE_NO_SHADOW_AUTO_BURN",
"when": "no shadow at the tree"
},
"arms": [
{
"id": "with one squadmate",
"change": {
"company": "1 Squadmate",
"leave": "Stay together"
},
"fix": {
"company": "1 Squadmate",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree",
"leave": "Stay together"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "with two squadmates",
"change": {
"company": "2 Squadmates",
"leave": "Stay together"
},
"fix": {
"company": "2 Squadmates",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree",
"leave": "Stay together"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "leave the squad",
"change": {
"company": "2 Squadmates",
"leave": "Leave them"
},
"fix": {
"company": "2 Squadmates",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree",
"leave": "Leave them"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "east first",
"change": {
"direction": "East"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "East",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "centre first",
"change": {
"direction": "Center"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "Center",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "face the first dragon",
"change": {
"react": "Respect / face it"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Respect / face it",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "charge the smaller cadet",
"change": {
"fight": "Charge the smaller cadet"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Charge the smaller cadet",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "charge the bigger cadet",
"change": {
"dagger": "Charge the bigger cadet anyway"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Charge the bigger cadet anyway",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "kill the bullies",
"change": {
"fate": "Killed the bullies yourself"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Killed the bullies yourself",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "leave the bullies",
"change": {
"fate": "Left bullies to the dragons"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Left bullies to the dragons",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "fork to the forest",
"change": {
"post": "Forest"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "Forest",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
},
{
"id": "fork east",
"change": {
"post": "East"
},
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "East",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 15
}
}
],
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"unknownArms": []
}
},
{
"id": "shadow-again",
"status": "running",
"question": "Is the shadow really gone after the first attempt?",
"question": "Does an account that saw the shadow, and died, see it again on the same path?",
"attempts": {
"from": 2,
"to": 4
},
"unit": "account",
"share": 1,
"exclusive": true,
"when": {
"sawShadowBefore": true
},
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
},
"burn": {
"reason": "TREE_NO_SHADOW_AUTO_BURN",
"when": "no shadow at the tree"
},
"arms": [
{
"id": "all",
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 12
}
}
],
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"unknownArms": []
}
},
{
"id": "second-attempt-same-path",
"status": "running",
"question": "Does an account that missed on its first attempt miss again on the same path?",
"attempts": {
"from": 2,
"to": 2
@@ -134,13 +531,139 @@
"share": 1,
"accounts": {
"every": 2,
"take": 1
"take": 1,
"offset": 0
},
"exclusive": true,
"when": {
"sawShadowBefore": false
},
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261112,
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
},
"burn": {
"reason": "TREE_NO_SHADOW_AUTO_BURN",
"when": "no shadow at the tree"
},
"arms": [
{
"id": "all",
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 60
}
}
],
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"unknownArms": []
}
},
{
"id": "veteran-repeat",
"status": "running",
"question": "Does an older account open up by repeating one path?",
"attempts": {
"from": 3,
"to": null
},
"unit": "account",
"share": 1,
"accounts": {
"every": 10,
"take": 1,
"offset": 0
},
"exclusive": true,
"when": {
"sawShadowBefore": false
},
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
},
"burn": {
"reason": "TREE_NO_SHADOW_AUTO_BURN",
"when": "no shadow at the tree"
},
"arms": [
{
"id": "all",
"fix": {
"company": "Alone",
"direction": "West",
"react": "Hold still",
"scream": "Investigate the scream",
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"fight": "Pause to assess",
"dagger": "Engage the smaller cadet",
"fate": "Squadmate's revenge",
"post": "West",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 300
}
}
],
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"unknownArms": []
}
},
{
"id": "veteran-variety",
"status": "running",
"question": "Does an older account open up by varying its choices?",
"attempts": {
"from": 3,
"to": null
},
"unit": "account",
"share": 1,
"accounts": {
"every": 10,
"take": 1,
"offset": 1
},
"exclusive": true,
"when": {
"sawShadowBefore": false
},
"target": "Black",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "shadow",
"rare": "yes"
@@ -157,11 +680,42 @@
"clearing": "Help your squadmate",
"hour": "Tree"
},
"cycle": {
"company": [
"Alone",
"1 Squadmate",
"2 Squadmates"
],
"direction": [
"West",
"East",
"Center"
],
"fight": [
"Pause to assess",
"Charge the smaller cadet",
"Charge between the bigger cadet and your squadmate"
],
"dagger": [
"Engage the smaller cadet",
"Charge the bigger cadet anyway"
],
"fate": [
"Killed the bullies yourself",
"Squadmate's revenge",
"Left bullies to the dragons"
],
"post": [
"Forest",
"West",
"East"
]
},
"progress": {
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 120
"planned": 300
}
}
],
@@ -181,11 +735,11 @@
"to": null
},
"unit": "attempt",
"share": 0.6,
"share": 0.5,
"target": "Blue",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261112,
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "meadow",
"rare": "Blue"
@@ -320,17 +874,17 @@
{
"id": "mapping",
"status": "running",
"question": "What does every branch of the valley lead to?",
"question": "What does every option on every screen lead to?",
"attempts": {
"from": 2,
"to": null
},
"unit": "attempt",
"share": 0.25,
"share": 0.35,
"target": "Blue",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "uniform",
"seed": 20261112,
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": null,
"burn": {
"reason": "NOT_TARGET_AUTO_BURN",
@@ -344,7 +898,7 @@
"runs": 0,
"observed": 0,
"rare": 0,
"planned": 600
"planned": 1000
}
}
],
@@ -368,7 +922,7 @@
"target": "Blue",
"objective": "eventually",
"sampling": "best",
"seed": 20261112,
"seed": 20261116,
"measures": {
"roll": "meadow",
"rare": "Blue"
@@ -404,5 +958,5 @@
}
}
],
"id": "ff265e6f994d"
"id": "4f436e3d81c0"
}
File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long